Difference Between FMEA & FMECA

by David Dunning; Updated September 26, 2017
Crew Exploration Vehicle Orbiting Earth.

FMEA, which stands for failure mode and effects analysis, and FMECA, or failure modes, effects and criticality analysis, are methods used to identify ways a product or process can fail. The basic methodology is the same in both processes, but there are important differences between them.

Qualitative Vs. Quantitative

FMEA provides only qualitative information. The process is used widely in industry as a what-if process. For example, NASA uses it as part of its flight assurance program for spacecraft. FMECA provides qualitative as well as limited quantitative information, which means capable of being measured. It attaches a level of criticality to failure modes. For example, the U.S. Army uses it to assess mission-critical equipment and systems.

Critical Analysis

FMECA is effectively an extension of FMEA. In order to perform FMECA, analysts must perform FMEA followed by critical analysis. FMEA identifies failure modes of a product or process and their effects, while CA ranks those failure modes in order of importance, according to failure rate and severity of failure.

Different Levels

Critical analysis does not add information to FMEA. CA limits the scope of FMECA to the failure modes identified by FMEA as requiring reliability centered maintenance.

About the Author

A full-time writer since 2006, David Dunning is a professional freelancer specializing in creative non-fiction. His work has appeared in "Golf Monthly," "Celtic Heritage," "Best of British" and numerous other magazines, as well as in the book "Defining Moments in History." Dunning has a Master of Science in computer science from the University of Kent.

Photo Credits

  • 3DSculptor/iStock/Getty Images
Cite this Article A tool to create a citation to reference this article Cite this Article